add option suppress_reply_directly_above to stop suppressing the reply directly above

added a bunch of debugging information to help diagnose weird positioning issues

app/assets/javascripts/discourse/models/post.js

@@ -30,7 +30,10 @@ Discourse.Post = Discourse.Model.extend({
   }.property('username'),
 
   showUserReplyTab: function() {
-    return this.get('reply_to_user') && (this.get('reply_to_post_number') < (this.get('post_number') - 1));
+    return this.get('reply_to_user') && (
+      !Discourse.SiteSettings.suppress_reply_directly_above ||
+      this.get('reply_to_post_number') < (this.get('post_number') - 1)
+    );
   }.property('reply_to_user', 'reply_to_post_number', 'post_number'),
 
   byTopicCreator: function() {

app/assets/javascripts/discourse/views/post_view.js

@@ -69,7 +69,16 @@ Discourse.PostView = Discourse.View.extend({
   // Toggle visibility of parent post
   toggleParent: function(e) {
     var postView = this;
+    var post = this.get('post');
     var $parent = this.$('.parent-post');
+    var inReplyTo = post.get('reply_to_post_number');
+
+    if (post.get('post_number') - 1 === inReplyTo) {
+      // true means ... avoid scroll if possible
+      Discourse.TopicView.jumpToPost(post.get('topic_id'), inReplyTo, true);
+      return;
+    }
+
     if (this.get('parentPost')) {
       $('nav', $parent).removeClass('toggled');
       // Don't animate on touch
@@ -80,11 +89,10 @@ Discourse.PostView = Discourse.View.extend({
         $parent.slideUp(function() { postView.set('parentPost', null); });
       }
     } else {
-      var post = this.get('post');
       this.set('loadingParent', true);
       $('nav', $parent).addClass('toggled');
 
-      Discourse.Post.loadByPostNumber(post.get('topic_id'), post.get('reply_to_post_number')).then(function(result) {
+      Discourse.Post.loadByPostNumber(post.get('topic_id'), inReplyTo).then(function(result) {
         postView.set('loadingParent', false);
         // Give the post a reference back to the topic
         result.topic = postView.get('post.topic');
@@ -159,9 +167,9 @@ Discourse.PostView = Discourse.View.extend({
   showLinkCounts: function() {
 
     var postView = this;
-    var link_counts;
+    var link_counts = this.get('post.link_counts');
 
-    if (link_counts = this.get('post.link_counts')) {
+    if (link_counts) {
       _.each(link_counts, function(lc) {
         if (lc.clicks > 0) {
           postView.$(".cooked a[href]").each(function() {

app/assets/javascripts/discourse/views/topic_view.js

@@ -329,30 +329,82 @@ Discourse.TopicView = Discourse.View.extend(Discourse.Scrolling, {
 Discourse.TopicView.reopenClass({
 
   // Scroll to a given post, if in the DOM. Returns whether it was in the DOM or not.
-  jumpToPost: function(topicId, postNumber) {
+  jumpToPost: function(topicId, postNumber, avoidScrollIfPossible) {
     Em.run.scheduleOnce('afterRender', function() {
 
+      var rows = $('.topic-post.ready');
+
       // Make sure we're looking at the topic we want to scroll to
       if (topicId !== parseInt($('#topic').data('topic-id'), 10)) { return false; }
 
       var $post = $("#post_" + postNumber);
       if ($post.length) {
-        if (postNumber === 1) {
+
-          $('html, body').scrollTop(0);
+        var postTop = $post.offset().top;
+        var highlight = true;
+
+        var header = $('header');
+        var title = $('#topic-title');
+        var expectedOffset = title.height() - header.find('.contents').height();
+        console.log(expectedOffset);
+
+        if (expectedOffset < 0) {
+          expectedOffset = 0;
+        }
+
+        var offset = (header.outerHeight(true) + expectedOffset);
+        var windowScrollTop = $('html, body').scrollTop();
+
+        if (avoidScrollIfPossible && postTop > windowScrollTop + offset && postTop < windowScrollTop + $(window).height() + 100) {
+          // in view
         } else {
-          var header = $('header');
+          // not in view ... bring into view
-          var title = $('#topic-title');
+          if (postNumber === 1) {
-          var expectedOffset = title.height() - header.find('.contents').height();
+            $(window).scrollTop(0);
+            highlight = false;
+          } else {
+            var desired = $post.offset().top - offset;
+            $(window).scrollTop(desired);
 
-          if (expectedOffset < 0) {
+            // TODO @Robin, I am seeing multiple events in chrome issued after
-            expectedOffset = 0;
+            // jumpToPost if I refresh a page, sometimes I see 2, sometimes 3
+            //
+            // 1. Where are they coming from?
+            // 2. On refresh we should only issue a single scrollTop
+            // 3. If you are scrolled down in BoingBoing desired sometimes is wrong
+            //      due to vanishing header, we should not be rendering it imho until after
+            //      we render the posts
+
+            var first = true;
+            var t = new Date();
+            console.log("DESIRED:" + desired);
+            var enforceDesired = function(){
+              if($(window).scrollTop() !== desired) {
+                console.log("GOT EVENT " + $(window).scrollTop());
+                console.log("Time " + (new Date() - t));
+                console.trace();
+                if(first) {
+                  $(window).scrollTop(desired);
+                  first = false;
+                }
+                // $(document).unbind("scroll", enforceDesired);
+              }
+            };
+
+            // uncomment this line to help debug this issue.
+            // $(document).scroll(enforceDesired);
           }
+        }
 
-          $('html, body').scrollTop($post.offset().top - (header.outerHeight(true) + expectedOffset));
+        if(highlight) {
-
           var $contents = $('.topic-body .contents', $post);
-          var originalCol = $contents.css('backgroundColor');
+          var origColor = $contents.data('orig-color') || $contents.css('backgroundColor');
-          $contents.css({ backgroundColor: "#ffffcc" }).animate({ backgroundColor: originalCol }, 2500);
+
+          $contents.data("orig-color", origColor);
+          $contents
+            .css({ backgroundColor: "#ffffcc" })
+            .stop()
+            .animate({ backgroundColor: origColor }, 2500);
         }
       }
     });

app/models/site_setting.rb

@@ -41,6 +41,7 @@ class SiteSetting < ActiveRecord::Base
   client_setting(:min_search_term_length, 3)
   client_setting(:flush_timings_secs, 5)
   client_setting(:suppress_reply_directly_below, true)
+  client_setting(:suppress_reply_directly_above, true)
   client_setting(:email_domains_blacklist, 'mailinator.com')
   client_setting(:email_domains_whitelist)
   client_setting(:version_checks, true)

config/locales/server.en.yml

@@ -514,6 +514,8 @@ en:
     system_username: "Username for the author of automated private messages sent by the forum"
     send_welcome_message: "Do new users get a welcome private message?"
     suppress_reply_directly_below: "Don't show reply count on a post when there is a single reply directly below"
+    suppress_reply_directly_above: "Don't show in-reply-to on a post when there is a single reply directly above"
+
     allow_index_in_robots_txt: "Site should be indexed by search engines (update robots.txt)"
     email_domains_blacklist: "A pipe-delimited list of email domains that are not allowed. Example: mailinator.com|trashmail.net"
     email_domains_whitelist: "A pipe-delimited list of email domains that users may register with. WARNING: Users with email domains other than those listed will not be allowed."