Commit Graph

15 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Fabian Boehm
bdfbdaafcc
Forbid subcommand keywords in variables-as-commands (#10249)
This stops you from doing e.g.

```fish
set pager command less
echo foo | $pager
```

Currently, it would run the command *builtin*, which can only do
`--search` and similar, and would most likely end up printing its own
help.

That means it very very likely won't work, and the code is misguided -
it is trying to defeat function resolution in a way that won't do what
the author wants it to.

The alternative would be to make the command *builtin* execute the
command, *but*

1. That would require rearchitecting and rewriting a bunch of it and
the parser
2. It would be a large footgun, in that `set EDITOR command foo` will
only ever work inside fish, but $EDITOR is also used outside.

I don't want to add a feature that we would immediately have to discourage.
2024-02-06 22:12:55 +01:00
Johannes Altmanninger
7df70e18f4 Add hint to error message about cmdsub in command position
We might end up allowing this but let's add some help for now.

See #5575
2023-11-18 12:26:45 +01:00
Fabian Boehm
b8424e425f fixup! 2
That'll teach me
2022-11-15 19:05:18 +01:00
Aaron Gyes
92698dff48 Unallowed command subst error: add missing newline and simplify
Fixes ommitted newline char shown after complete -n'(foo)'
Also axes the 'contains syntax errors' line before the error.
Update tests

before
> complete -n'(foo)'
complete: Condition '(foo)' contained a syntax error
complete: Command substitutions not allowed⏎

after
> complete -n'(foo)'
complete: -n '(foo)': command substitutions not allowed here
2022-10-26 19:58:40 -07:00
Fabian Boehm
4b921cbc08 Clamp error carets to the end instead of refusing to print
This skipped printing a "^" line if the start or length of the error
was longer than the source.

That seems like the correc thing at first glance, however it means
that the caret line isn't skipped *if the file goes on*.

So, for example

```fish
echo "$abc["
```

by itself, in a file or via `fish -c`, would not print an error, but

```fish
echo "$abc["
true
```

would. That's not a great way to print errors.

So instead we just.. imagine the start was at most at the end.

The underlying issue why `echo "$abc["` causes this is that `wcstol`
didn't move the end pointer for the index value (because there is no
number there). I'd fix this, but apparently some of
our recursive variable calls absolutely rely on this position value.
2022-08-12 18:38:47 +02:00
Fabian Boehm
eaf92918e6 Fix error offset for command (foo)
This used the decorated statement offset when the expansion errors
refer to the command without decoration.
2022-08-12 18:38:47 +02:00
Johannes Altmanninger
745129e825 builtin string: don't print final newline if it's missing from stdin
A command like "printf nonewline | sed s/x/y/" does not print a
concluding newline, whereas "printf nnl | string replace x y" does.
This is an edge case -- usually the user input does have a newline at
the end -- but it seems still better for this command to just forward
the user's data.

Teach most string subcommands to check if stdin is missing the trailing
newline, and stop adding one in that case.
This does not apply when input is read from commandline arguments.

* Most subcommands stop adding the final newline, because they don't
  really care about newlines, so besides their normal processing,
  they just want to preserve user input. They are:
  * string collect
  * string escape/unescape
  * string join¹
  * string lower/upper
  * string pad
  * string replace
  * string repeat
  * string sub
  * string trim

* string match keeps adding the newline, following "grep". Additionally,
  for string match --regex, it's important to output capture groups
  separated by newlines, resulting in multiple output lines for an
  input line. So it is not obvious where to leave out the newline.

* string split/split0 keep adding the newline for the same reason --
  they are meant to output multiple elements for a single input line.

¹) string join0 is not changed because it already printed a trailing
   zero byte instead of the trailing newline. This is consistent
   with other tools like "find -print0".

Closes #3847
2021-11-27 19:11:24 +01:00
David Adam
a8fddf3d9b add tests for zero-index expressions
See 5326462116 / #8213.
2021-08-17 12:41:03 +08:00
Fabian Homborg
29e9f4838a Run parse_util_detect_errors on -c commands
This didn't do all the syntax checks, so something like

    fish -c 'echo foo; and $status'

complained of a missing command `0` (i.e. $status), and

    fish -c 'echo foo | exec grep'

hit an assert!

So we do what read_ni does, parse each command into an ast, run
parse_util_detect_errors on it if it worked and then eval the ast.

It is possible to do this neater by modifying parser::eval, but I
can't find where.
2021-07-27 18:37:20 +02:00
Fabian Homborg
3a1bc33cad tests: Remove leftover reference to "../test/root/bin/fish"
We have that in a variable now.
2020-03-28 15:46:47 +01:00
Fabian Homborg
52b5afe2f8 Port expansion test to littlecheck
This one really is a lot easier to follow
2020-03-16 21:21:10 +01:00
Fabian Homborg
9367d4ff71 Reindent functions to remove useless quotes
This does not include checks/function.fish because that currently
includes a "; end" in a message that indent would remove, breaking the test.
2020-03-09 19:46:43 +01:00
Fabian Homborg
849f27912e Port parameter_expansion test to littlecheck
Just put it in expansion.fish.
2020-02-08 11:16:53 +01:00
Fabian Homborg
bf7629462a Port some small tests to littlecheck 2020-02-08 10:38:11 +01:00
Johannes Altmanninger
f91c725ff0 Fix caret position of invalid expansion in command position
Fixes #5812
2019-10-06 13:43:05 -07:00