There are many places where we want to treat a missing variable the same as
a variable with an empty value.
In C++ we handle this by branching on maybe_t<env_var_t>::missing_or_empty().
If it returns false, we go on to access maybe_t<env_var_t>::value() aka
operator*.
In Rust, Environment::get() will return an Option<EnvVar>.
We could define a MissingOrEmpty trait and implement it for Option<EnvVar>.
However that will still leave us with ugly calls to Option::unwrap()
(by convention Rust does use shorthands like *).
Let's add a variable getter that returns none for empty variables.
This isn't the same as "join"/"join0", where one is just a special
case of the other.
These are two different, if basically opposite commands.
But more importantly this was a huge mess and the formatting was broken.
Except for the indent visitor bits.
Tests for parse_util_detect_errors* are not ported yet because they depend
on expand.h (and operation_context.h which depends on env.h).
This caused math to assert out because it never wrote into the buffer.
Now, presumably it wrote somewhere but I don't know where, so fixing
this seems like a good idea.
Fixes#9735.
The translation is fairly direct though it adds some duplication, for example
there are multiple "match" statements that mimic function overloading.
Rust has no overloading, and we cannot have generic methods in the Node trait
(due to a Rust limitation, the error is like "cannot be made into an object")
so we include the type name in method names.
Give clients like "indent_visitor_t" a Rust companion ("IndentVisitor")
that takes care of the AST traversal while the AST consumption remains
in C++ for now. In future, "IndentVisitor" should absorb the entirety of
"indent_visitor_t". This pattern requires that "fish_indent" be exposed
includable header to the CXX bridge.
Alternatively, we could define FFI wrappers for recursive AST traversal.
Rust requires we separate the AST visitors for "mut" and "const"
scenarios. Take this opportunity to concretize both visitors:
The only client that requires mutable access is the populator. To match the
structure of the C++ populator which makes heavy use of function overloading,
we need to add a bunch of functions to the trait. Since there is no other
mutable visit, this seems acceptable.
The "const" visitors never use "will_visit_fields_of()" or
"did_visit_fields_of()", so remove them (though this is debatable).
Like in the C++ implementation, the AST nodes themselves are largely defined
via macros. Union fields like "Statement" and "ArgumentOrRedirection"
do currently not use macros but may in future.
This commit also introduces a precedent for a type that is defined in one
CXX bridge and used in another one - "ParseErrorList". To make this work
we need to manually define "ExternType".
There is one annoyance with CXX: functions that take explicit lifetime
parameters require to be marked as unsafe. This makes little sense
because functions that return `&Foo` with implicit lifetime can be
misused the same way on the C++ side.
One notable change is that we cannot directly port "find_block_open_keyword()"
(which is used to compute an error) because it relies on the stack of visited
nodes. We cannot modify a stack of node references while we do the "mut"
walk. Happily, an idiomatic solution is easy: we can tell the AST visitor
to backtrack to the parent node and create the error there.
Since "node_t::accept_base" is no longer a template we don't need the
"node_visitation_t" trampoline anymore.
The added copying at the FFI boundary makes things slower (memcpy dominates
the profile) but it's not unusable, which is good news:
$ hyperfine ./fish.{old,new}" -c 'source ../share/completions/git.fish'"
Benchmark 1: ./fish.old -c 'source ../share/completions/git.fish'
Time (mean ± σ): 195.5 ms ± 2.9 ms [User: 190.1 ms, System: 4.4 ms]
Range (min … max): 193.2 ms … 205.1 ms 15 runs
Benchmark 2: ./fish.new -c 'source ../share/completions/git.fish'
Time (mean ± σ): 677.5 ms ± 62.0 ms [User: 665.4 ms, System: 10.0 ms]
Range (min … max): 611.7 ms … 805.5 ms 10 runs
Summary
'./fish.old -c 'source ../share/completions/git.fish'' ran
3.47 ± 0.32 times faster than './fish.new -c 'source ../share/completions/git.fish''
Leftovers:
- Enum variants are still snakecase; I didn't get around to changing this yet.
- "ast_type_to_string()" still returns a snakecase name. This could be
changed since it's not user visible.
A JobId is not supposed to convert to other types.
Since this type is defined as NonZeroU32 (which cannot be -1), we need to
add some conversion functions to match the C++ behavior.
Overall, it would have been better to keep using the C++ type.
The conversion to usize is used for array accesses, so negative values
would cause crashes either way. Let's do it earlier so we can get rid of
the suspect C-style cast.