checkout/adrs/0153-checkout-v2.md

ADR 0153: Checkout v2

Date: 2019-10-21

Status: Accepted

Context

This ADR details the behavior for actions/checkout@v2.

The new action will be written in typescript. We are moving away from runner-plugin actions.

We want to take this opportunity to make behavioral changes, from v1. This document is scoped to those differences.

Decision

Inputs

  repository:
    description: 'Repository name with owner. For example, actions/checkout'
    default: ${{ github.repository }}
  ref:
    description: >
      The branch, tag or SHA to checkout. When checking out the repository that
      triggered a workflow, this defaults to the reference or SHA for that
      event.  Otherwise, defaults to `master`.      
  token:
    description: >
      Personal access token (PAT) used to fetch the repository. The PAT is configured
      with the local git config, which enables your scripts to run authenticated git
      commands. The post-job step removes the PAT. [Learn more about creating and using
      encrypted secrets](https://help.github.com/en/actions/automating-your-workflow-with-github-actions/creating-and-using-encrypted-secrets)      
    default: ${{ github.token }}
  ssh-key:
    description: >
      SSH key used to fetch the repository. SSH key is configured with the local
      git config, which enables your scripts to run authenticated git commands.
      The post-job step removes the SSH key. [Learn more about creating and using
      encrypted secrets](https://help.github.com/en/actions/automating-your-workflow-with-github-actions/creating-and-using-encrypted-secrets)      
  ssh-known-hosts:
    description: >
      Known hosts in addition to the user and global host key database. The public
      SSH keys for a host may be obtained using the utility `ssh-keyscan`. For example,
      `ssh-keyscan github.com`. The public key for github.com is always implicitly added.      
  ssh-strict:
    description: 'Whether to perform strict host key checking'
    default: true
  persist-credentials:
    description: 'Whether to configure the token or SSH key with the local git config'
    default: true
  path:
    description: 'Relative path under $GITHUB_WORKSPACE to place the repository'
  clean:
    description: 'Whether to execute `git clean -ffdx && git reset --hard HEAD` before fetching'
    default: true
  fetch-depth:
    description: 'Number of commits to fetch. 0 indicates all history.'
    default: 1
  lfs:
    description: 'Whether to download Git-LFS files'
    default: false
  submodules:
    description: >
      Whether to checkout submodules: `true` to checkout submodules or `recursive` to
      recursively checkout submodules.      
    default: 'false'

Note:

• SSH support is new
• persist-credentials is new
• path behavior is different (refer below for details)

Fallback to GitHub API

When a sufficient version of git is not in the PATH, fallback to the web API to download a tarball/zipball.

Note:

• LFS files are not included in the archive. Therefore fail if LFS is set to true.
• Submodules are also not included in the archive.

Persist credentials

The credentials will be persisted on disk. This will allow users to script authenticated git commands, like git fetch.

A post script will remove the credentials (cleanup for self-hosted).

Users may opt-out by specifying persist-credentials: false

Note:

• Users scripting git commit may need to set the username and email. The service does not provide any reasonable default value. Users can add git config user.name <NAME> and git config user.email <EMAIL>. We will document this guidance.

PAT

When using the ${{github.token}} or a PAT, the token will be persisted in the local git config. The config key http.https://github.com/.extraheader enables an auth header to be specified on all authenticated commands AUTHORIZATION: basic <BASE64_U:P>.

Note:

• The auth header is scoped to all of github http.https://github.com/.extraheader
  • Additional public remotes also just work.
  • If users want to authenticate to an additional private remote, they should provide the token input.

SSH key

The SSH key will be written to disk under the $RUNNER_TEMP directory. The SSH key will
be removed by the action's post-job hook. Additionally, RUNNER_TEMP is cleared by the
runner between jobs.

The SSH key must be written with strict file permissions. The SSH client requires the file
to be read/write for the user, and not accessible by others.

The user host key database (~/.ssh/known_hosts) will be copied to a unique file under
$RUNNER_TEMP. And values from the input ssh-known-hosts will be added to the file.

The SSH command will be overridden for the local git config:

git config core.sshCommand 'ssh -i "$RUNNER_TEMP/path-to-ssh-key" -o StrictHostKeyChecking=yes -o CheckHostIP=no -o "UserKnownHostsFile=$RUNNER_TEMP/path-to-known-hosts"'

When the input ssh-strict is set to false, the options CheckHostIP and StrictHostKeyChecking will not be overridden.

Note:

• When ssh-strict is set to true (default), the SSH option CheckHostIP can safely be disabled.
  Strict host checking verifies the server's public key. Therefore, IP verification is unnecessary
  and noisy. For example:

  Warning: Permanently added the RSA host key for IP address '140.82.113.4' to the list of known hosts.

• Since GIT_SSH_COMMAND overrides core.sshCommand, temporarily set the env var when fetching the repo. When creds
  are persisted, core.sshCommand is leveraged to avoid multiple checkout steps stomping over each other.
• Modify actions/runner to mount RUNNER_TEMP to enable scripting authenticated git commands from a container action.
• Refer here for SSH config details.

Fetch behavior

Fetch only the SHA being built and set depth=1. This significantly reduces the fetch time for large repos.

If a SHA isn't available (e.g. multi repo), then fetch only the specified ref with depth=1.

The input fetch-depth can be used to control the depth.

Note:

• Fetching a single commit is supported by Git wire protocol version 2. The git client uses protocol version 0 by default. The desired protocol version can be overridden in the git config or on the fetch command line invocation (-c protocol.version=2). We will override on the fetch command line, for transparency.
• Git client version 2.18+ (released June 2018) is required for wire protocol version 2.

Checkout behavior

For CI, checkout will create a local ref with the upstream set. This allows users to script git as they normally would.

For PR, continue to checkout detached head. The PR branch is special - the branch and merge commit are created by the server. It doesn't match a users' local workflow.

Note:

• Consider deleting all local refs during cleanup if that helps avoid collisions. More testing required.

Path

For the mainline scenario, the disk-layout behavior remains the same.

Remember, given the repo johndoe/foo, the mainline disk layout looks like:

GITHUB_WORKSPACE=/home/runner/work/foo/foo
RUNNER_WORKSPACE=/home/runner/work/foo

V2 introduces a new contraint on the checkout path. The location must now be under github.workspace. Whereas the checkout@v1 constraint was one level up, under runner.workspace.

V2 no longer changes github.workspace to follow wherever the self repo is checked-out.

These behavioral changes align better with container actions. The documented filesystem contract is:

• /github/home
• /github/workspace - Note: GitHub Actions must be run by the default Docker user (root). Ensure your Dockerfile does not set the USER instruction, otherwise you will not be able to access GITHUB_WORKSPACE.
• /github/workflow

Note:

• The tracking config will not be updated to reflect the path of the workflow repo.
• Any existing workflow repo will not be moved when the checkout path changes. In fact some customers want to checkout the workflow repo twice, side by side against different branches.
• Actions that need to operate only against the root of the self repo, should expose a path input.

Default value for path input

The path input will default to ./ which is rooted against github.workspace.

This default fits the mainline scenario well: single checkout

For multi-checkout, users must specify the path input for at least one of the repositories.

Note:

• An alternative is for the self repo to default to ./ and other repos default to <REPO_NAME>. However nested layout is an atypical git layout and therefore is not a good default. Users should supply the path info.

Example - Nested layout

The following example checks-out two repositories and creates a nested layout.

# Self repo - Checkout to $GITHUB_WORKSPACE
- uses: checkout@v2

# Other repo - Checkout to $GITHUB_WORKSPACE/myscripts
- uses: checkout@v2
  with:
    repository: myorg/myscripts
    path: myscripts

Example - Side by side layout

The following example checks-out two repositories and creates a side-by-side layout.

# Self repo - Checkout to $GITHUB_WORKSPACE/foo
- uses: checkout@v2
  with:
    path: foo

# Other repo - Checkout to $GITHUB_WORKSPACE/myscripts
- uses: checkout@v2
  with:
    repository: myorg/myscripts
    path: myscripts

Path impact to problem matchers

Problem matchers associate the source files with annotations.

Today the runner verifies the source file is under the github.workspace. Otherwise the source file property is dropped.

Multi-checkout complicates the matter. However even today submodules may cause this heuristic to be inaccurate.

A better solution is:

Given a source file path, walk up the directories until the first .git/config is found. Check if it matches the self repo (url = https://github.com/OWNER/REPO). If not, drop the source file path.

Submodules

With both PAT and SSH key support, we should be able to provide frictionless support for
submodules scenarios: recursive, non-recursive, relative submodule paths.

When fetching submodules, follow the fetch-depth settings.

Credentials will be persisted in the submodules local git config too.

Port to typescript

The checkout action should be a typescript action on the GitHub graph, for the following reasons:

• Enables customers to fork the checkout repo and modify
• Serves as an example for customers
• Demystifies the checkout action manifest
• Simplifies the runner
• Reduce the amount of runner code to port (if we ever do)

Note:

• This means job-container images will need git in the PATH, for checkout.

Branching strategy and release tags

• Create a servicing branch for V1: releases/v1
• Merge the changes into master
• Release using a new tag preview
• When stable, release using a new tag v2

Consequences

• Update the checkout action and readme
• Update samples to consume actions/checkout@v2
• Job containers now require git in the PATH for checkout, otherwise fallback to REST API
• Minimum git version 2.18
• Update problem matcher logic regarding source file verification (runner)