**mergerfs** is a union filesystem geared towards simplifying storage and management of files across numerous commodity storage devices. It is similar to **mhddfs**, **unionfs**, and **aufs**.
mergerfs logically merges multiple paths together. Think a union of sets. The file/s or directory/s acted on or presented through mergerfs are based on the policy chosen for that particular action. Read more about policies below.
mergerfs does **not** support the copy-on-write (CoW) behavior found in **aufs** and **overlayfs**. You can **not** mount a read-only filesystem and write to it. However, mergerfs will ignore read-only drives when creating new files so you can mix read-write and read-only drives. It also does **not** split data across drives. It is not RAID0 / striping. It is simply a union.
* **minfreespace=SIZE**: The minimum space value used for creation policies. Understands 'K', 'M', and 'G' to represent kilobyte, megabyte, and gigabyte respectively. (default: 4G)
* **moveonenospc=BOOL|POLICY**: When enabled if a **write** fails with **ENOSPC** (no space left on device) or **EDQUOT** (disk quota exceeded) the policy selected will run to find a new location for the file. An attempt to move the file to that branch will occur (keeping all metadata possible) and if successful the original is unlinked and the write retried. (default: false, true = mfs)
* **use_ino**: Causes mergerfs to supply file/directory inodes rather than libfuse. While not a default it is recommended it be enabled so that linked files share the same inode value.
* **dropcacheonclose=BOOL**: When a file is requested to be closed call `posix_fadvise` on it first to instruct the kernel that we no longer need the data and it can drop its cache. Recommended when **cache.files=partial|full|auto-full** to limit double caching. (default: false)
* **symlinkify=BOOL**: When enabled and a file is not writable and its mtime or ctime is older than **symlinkify_timeout** files will be reported as symlinks to the original files. Please read more below before using. (default: false)
* **symlinkify_timeout=INT**: Time to wait, in seconds, to activate the **symlinkify** behavior. (default: 3600)
* **nullrw=BOOL**: Turns reads and writes into no-ops. The request will succeed but do nothing. Useful for benchmarking mergerfs. (default: false)
* **ignorepponrename=BOOL**: Ignore path preserving on rename. Typically rename and link act differently depending on the policy of `create` (read below). Enabling this will cause rename and link to always use the non-path preserving behavior. This means files, when renamed or linked, will stay on the same drive. (default: false)
* **security_capability=BOOL**: If false return ENOATTR when xattr security.capability is queried. (default: true)
* **xattr=passthrough|noattr|nosys**: Runtime control of xattrs. Default is to passthrough xattr requests. 'noattr' will short circuit as if nothing exists. 'nosys' will respond with ENOSYS as if xattrs are not supported or disabled. (default: passthrough)
* **link_cow=BOOL**: When enabled if a regular file is opened which has a link count > 1 it will copy the file to a temporary file and rename over the original. Breaking the link and providing a basic copy-on-write function similar to cow-shell. (default: false)
* **statfs=base|full**: Controls how statfs works. 'base' means it will always use all branches in statfs calculations. 'full' is in effect path preserving and only includes drives where the path exists. (default: base)
* **statfs_ignore=none|ro|nc**: 'ro' will cause statfs calculations to ignore available space for branches mounted or tagged as 'read-only' or 'no create'. 'nc' will ignore available space for branches tagged as 'no create'. (default: none)
* **posix_acl=BOOL**: Enable POSIX ACL support (if supported by kernel and underlying filesystem). (default: false)
* **async_read=BOOL**: Perform reads asynchronously. If disabled or unavailable the kernel will ensure there is at most one pending read request per file handle and will attempt to order requests by offset. (default: true)
* **fuse_msg_size=INT**: Set the max number of pages per FUSE message. Only available on Linux >= 4.20 and ignored otherwise. (min: 1; max: 256; default: 256)
* **threads=INT**: Number of threads to use in multithreaded mode. When set to zero it will attempt to discover and use the number of logical cores. If the lookup fails it will fall back to using 4. If the thread count is set negative it will look up the number of cores then divide by the absolute value. ie. threads=-2 on an 8 core machine will result in 8 / 2 = 4 threads. There will always be at least 1 thread. NOTE: higher number of threads increases parallelism but usually decreases throughput. (default: 0)
* **fsname=STR**: Sets the name of the filesystem as seen in **mount**, **df**, etc. Defaults to a list of the source paths concatenated together with the longest common prefix removed.
* **func.FUNC=POLICY**: Sets the specific FUSE function's policy. See below for the list of value types. Example: **func.getattr=newest**
* **category.CATEGORY=POLICY**: Sets policy of all FUSE functions in the provided category. See POLICIES section for defaults. Example: **category.create=mfs**
**NOTE:** Options are evaluated in the order listed so if the options are **func.rmdir=rand,category.action=ff** the **action** category setting will override the **rmdir** setting.
The 'branches' (formerly 'srcmounts') argument is a colon (':') delimited list of paths to be pooled together. It does not matter if the paths are on the same or different drives nor does it matter the filesystem. Used and available space will not be duplicated for paths on the same device and any features which aren't supported by the underlying filesystem (such as file attributes or extended attributes) will return the appropriate errors.
To make it easier to include multiple branches mergerfs supports [globbing](http://linux.die.net/man/7/glob). **The globbing tokens MUST be escaped when using via the shell else the shell itself will apply the glob itself.**
Each branch can have a suffix of `=RW` (read / write), `=RO` (read-only), or `=NC` (no create). These suffixes work with globs as well and will apply to each path found. `RW` is the default behavior and those paths will be eligible for all policy categories. `RO` will exclude those paths from `create` and `action` policies (just as a filesystem being mounted `ro` would). `NC` will exclude those paths from `create` policies (you can't create but you can change / delete).
**NOTE:** the globbing is done at mount or xattr update time (see below). If a new directory is added matching the glob after the fact it will not be automatically included.
Inodes (st_ino) are unique identifiers within a filesystem. Each mounted filesystem has device ID (st_dev) as well and together they can uniquely identify a file on the whole of the system. Entries on the same device with the same inode are in fact references to the same underlying file. It is a many to one relationship between names and an inode. Directories, however, do not have multiple links on most systems due to the complexity they add.
FUSE allows the server (mergerfs) to set inode values but not device IDs. Creating an inode value is somewhat complex in mergerfs' case as files aren't really in its control. If a policy changes what directory or file is to be selected or something changes out of band it becomes unclear what value should be used. Most software does not to care what the values are but those that do often break if a value changes unexpectedly. The tool `find` will abort a directory walk if it sees a directory inode change. NFS will return stale handle errors if the inode changes out of band. File dedup tools will usually leverage device ids and inodes as a shortcut in searching for duplicate files and would resort to full file comparisons should it find different inode values.
mergerfs offers multiple ways to calculate the inode in hopes of covering different usecases.
* passthrough: Passes through the underlying inode value. Mostly intended for testing as using this does not address any of the problems mentioned above and could confuse file deduplication software as inodes from different filesystems can be the same.
* path-hash: Hashes the relative path of the entry in question. The underlying file's values are completely ignored. This means the inode value will always be the same for that file path. This is useful when using NFS and you make changes out of band such as copy data between branches. This also means that entries that do point to the same file will not be recognizable via inodes. That **does not** mean hard links don't work. They will.
* devino-hash: Hashes the device id and inode of the underlying entry. This won't prevent issues with NFS should the policy pick a different file or files move out of band but will present the same inode for underlying files that do too.
* hybrid-hash: Performs `path-hash` on directories and `devino-hash` on other file types. Since directories can't have hard links the static value won't make a difference and the files will get values useful for finding duplicates. Probably the best to use if not using NFS. As such it is the default.
While there is a risk of hash collision in tests of a couple million entries there were zero collisions. Unlike a typical filesystem FUSE filesystems can reuse inodes and not refer to the same entry. The internal identifier used to reference a file in FUSE is different from the inode value presented. The former is the `nodeid` and is actually a tuple of 2 64bit values: `nodeid` and `generation`. This tuple is not client facing. The inode that is presented to the client is passed through the kernel uninterpreted.
From FUSE docs regarding `use_ino`:
```
Honor the st_ino field in the functions getattr() and
fill_dir(). This value is used to fill in the st_ino field
in the stat(2), lstat(2), fstat(2) functions and the d_ino
field in the readdir(2) function. The filesystem does not
have to guarantee uniqueness, however some applications
rely on this value being unique for the whole filesystem.
Note that this does *not* affect the inode that libfuse
and the kernel use internally (also called the "nodeid").
```
In the future the `use_ino` option will probably be removed as this feature should replace the original libfuse inode calculation strategy. Currently you still need to use `use_ino` in order to enable `inodecalc`.
FUSE applications communicate with the kernel over a special character device: `/dev/fuse`. A large portion of the overhead associated with FUSE is the cost of going back and forth from user space and kernel space over that device. Generally speaking the fewer trips needed the better the performance will be. Reducing the number of trips can be done a number of ways. Kernel level caching and increasing message sizes being two significant ones. When it comes to reads and writes if the message size is doubled the number of trips are approximately halved.
In Linux 4.20 a new feature was added allowing the negotiation of the max message size. Since the size is in multiples of [pages](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Page_(computer_memory)) the feature is called `max_pages`. There is a maximum `max_pages` value of 256 (1MiB) and minimum of 1 (4KiB). The default used by Linux >=4.20, and hardcoded value used before 4.20, is 32 (128KiB). In mergerfs its referred to as `fuse_msg_size` to make it clear what it impacts and provide some abstraction.
Since there should be no downsides to increasing `fuse_msg_size` / `max_pages`, outside a minor bump in RAM usage due to larger message buffers, mergerfs defaults the value to 256. On kernels before 4.20 the value has no effect. The reason the value is configurable is to enable experimentation and benchmarking. See the BENCHMARKING section for examples.
Due to the levels of indirection introduced by mergerfs and the underlying technology FUSE there can be varying levels of performance degradation. This feature will turn non-directories which are not writable into symlinks to the original file found by the `readlink` policy after the mtime and ctime are older than the timeout.
**WARNING:** The current implementation has a known issue in which if the file is open and being used when the file is converted to a symlink then the application which has that file open will receive an error when using it. This is unlikely to occur in practice but is something to keep in mind.
**WARNING:** Some backup solutions, such as CrashPlan, do not backup the target of a symlink. If using this feature it will be necessary to point any backup software to the original drives or configure the software to follow symlinks if such an option is available. Alternatively create two mounts. One for backup and one for general consumption.
Due to how FUSE works there is an overhead to all requests made to a FUSE filesystem that wouldn't exist for an in kernel one. Meaning that even a simple passthrough will have some slowdown. However, generally the overhead is minimal in comparison to the cost of the underlying I/O. By disabling the underlying I/O we can test the theoretical performance boundaries.
By enabling `nullrw` mergerfs will work as it always does **except** that all reads and writes will be no-ops. A write will succeed (the size of the write will be returned as if it were successful) but mergerfs does nothing with the data it was given. Similarly a read will return the size requested but won't touch the buffer.
Runtime extended attribute support can be managed via the `xattr` option. By default it will passthrough any xattr calls. Given xattr support is rarely used and can have significant performance implications mergerfs allows it to be disabled at runtime. The performance problems mostly comes when file caching is enabled. The kernel will send a `getxattr` for `security.capability`*before every single write*. It doesn't cache the responses to any `getxattr`. This might be addressed in the future but for now mergerfs can really only offer the following workarounds.
`noattr` will cause mergerfs to short circuit all xattr calls and return ENOATTR where appropriate. mergerfs still gets all the requests but they will not be forwarded on to the underlying filesystems. The runtime control will still function in this mode.
`nosys` will cause mergerfs to return ENOSYS for any xattr call. The difference with `noattr` is that the kernel will cache this fact and itself short circuit future calls. This is more efficient than `noattr` but will cause mergerfs' runtime control via the hidden file to stop working.
The POSIX filesystem API is made up of a number of functions. **creat**, **stat**, **chown**, etc. In mergerfs most of the core functions are grouped into 3 categories: **action**, **create**, and **search**. These functions and categories can be assigned a policy which dictates what file or directory is chosen when performing that behavior. Any policy can be assigned to a function or category though some may not be very useful in practice. For instance: **rand** (random) may be useful for file creation (create) but could lead to very odd behavior if used for `chmod` if there were more than one copy of the file.
Some functions, listed in the category `N/A` below, can not be assigned the normal policies. All functions which work on file handles use the handle which was acquired by `open` or `create`. `readdir` has no real need for a policy given the purpose is merely to return a list of entries in a directory. `statfs`'s behavior can be modified via other options. That said many times the current FUSE kernel driver will not always provide the file handle when a client calls `fgetattr`, `fchown`, `fchmod`, `futimens`, `ftruncate`, etc. This means it will call the regular, path based, versions.
When using policies which are based on a branch's available space the base path provided is used. Not the full path to the file in question. Meaning that sub mounts won't be considered in the space calculations. The reason is that it doesn't really work for non-path preserving policies and can lead to non-obvious behaviors.
Policies basically search branches and create a list of files / paths for functions to work on. The policy is responsible for filtering and sorting. The policy type defines the sorting but filtering is mostly uniform as described below.
* All **action** policies will filter out branches which are mounted **read-only** or tagged as **RO (read-only)**.
* All **create** policies will filter out branches which are mounted **read-only**, tagged **RO (read-only)** or **NC (no create)**, or has available space less than `minfreespace`.
If all branches are filtered an error will be returned. Typically **EROFS** (read-only filesystem) or **ENOSPC** (no space left on device) depending on the reasons.
| all | Search category: same as **epall**. Action category: same as **epall**. Create category: for **mkdir**, **mknod**, and **symlink** it will apply to all branches. **create** works like **ff**. |
| epall (existing path, all) | Search category: same as **epff** (but more expensive because it doesn't stop after finding a valid branch). Action category: apply to all found. Create category: for **mkdir**, **mknod**, and **symlink** it will apply to all found. **create** works like **epff** (but more expensive because it doesn't stop after finding a valid branch). |
| epff (existing path, first found) | Given the order of the branches, as defined at mount time or configured at runtime, act on the first one found where the relative path exists. |
| eplfs (existing path, least free space) | Of all the branches on which the relative path exists choose the drive with the least free space. |
| eplus (existing path, least used space) | Of all the branches on which the relative path exists choose the drive with the least used space. |
| epmfs (existing path, most free space) | Of all the branches on which the relative path exists choose the drive with the most free space. |
| ff (first found) | Search category: same as **epff**. Action category: same as **epff**. Create category: Given the order of the drives, as defined at mount time or configured at runtime, act on the first one found. |
| lfs (least free space) | Search category: same as **eplfs**. Action category: same as **eplfs**. Create category: Pick the drive with the least available free space. |
| lus (least used space) | Search category: same as **eplus**. Action category: same as **eplus**. Create category: Pick the drive with the least used space. |
| mfs (most free space) | Search category: same as **epmfs**. Action category: same as **epmfs**. Create category: Pick the drive with the most available free space. |
| newest | Pick the file / directory with the largest mtime. |
**NOTE:** If you are using an underlying filesystem that reserves blocks such as ext2, ext3, or ext4 be aware that mergerfs respects the reservation by using `f_bavail` (number of free blocks for unprivileged users) rather than `f_bfree` (number of free blocks) in policy calculations. **df** does NOT use `f_bavail`, it uses `f_bfree`, so direct comparisons between **df** output and mergerfs' policies is not appropriate.
When `ioctl` is used with an open file then it will use the file handle which was created at the original `open` call. However, when using `ioctl` with a directory mergerfs will use the `open` policy to find the directory to act on.
#### unlink
In FUSE there is an opaque "file handle" which is created by `open`, `create`, or `opendir`, passed to the kernel, and then is passed back to the FUSE userland application by the kernel. Unfortunately, the FUSE kernel driver does not always send the file handle when it theoretically could/should. This complicates certain behaviors / workflows particularly in the high level API. As a result mergerfs is currently doing a few hacky things.
libfuse2 and libfuse3, when using the high level API, will rename names to `.fuse_hiddenXXXXXX` if the file is open when unlinked or renamed over. It does this so the file is still available when a request referencing the now missing file is made. This file however keeps a `rmdir` from succeeding and can be picked up by software reading directories.
The change mergerfs has done is that if a file is open when an unlink or rename happens it will open the file and keep it open till closed by all those who opened it prior. When a request comes in referencing that file and it doesn't include a file handle it will instead use the file handle created at unlink/rename time.
This won't result in technically proper behavior but close enough for many usecases.
The plan is to rewrite mergerfs to use the low level API so these invasive libfuse changes are no longer necessary.
**NOTE:** If you're receiving errors from software when files are moved / renamed / linked then you should consider changing the create policy to one which is **not** path preserving, enabling `ignorepponrename`, or contacting the author of the offending software and requesting that `EXDEV` (cross device / improper link) be properly handled.
`rename` and `link` are tricky functions in a union filesystem. `rename` only works within a single filesystem or device. If a rename can't be done atomically due to the source and destination paths existing on different mount points it will return **-1** with **errno = EXDEV** (cross device / improper link). So if a `rename`'s source and target are on different drives within the pool it creates an issue.
Originally mergerfs would return EXDEV whenever a rename was requested which was cross directory in any way. This made the code simple and was technically compliant with POSIX requirements. However, many applications fail to handle EXDEV at all and treat it as a normal error or otherwise handle it poorly. Such apps include: gvfsd-fuse v1.20.3 and prior, Finder / CIFS/SMB client in Apple OSX 10.9+, NZBGet, Samba's recycling bin feature.
[readdir](http://linux.die.net/man/3/readdir) is different from all other filesystem functions. While it could have its own set of policies to tweak its behavior at this time it provides a simple union of files and directories found. Remember that any action or information queried about these files and directories come from the respective function. For instance: an **ls** is a **readdir** and for each file/directory returned **getattr** is called. Meaning the policy of **getattr** is responsible for choosing the file/directory which is the source of the metadata you see in an **ls**.
[statvfs](http://linux.die.net/man/2/statvfs) normalizes the source drives based on the fragment size and sums the number of adjusted blocks and inodes. This means you will see the combined space of all sources. Total, used, and free. The sources however are dedupped based on the drive so multiple sources on the same drive will not result in double counting its space. Filesystems mounted further down the tree of the branch will not be included when checking the mount's stats.
The original runtime config API was via xattr calls. This however became an issue when needing to disable xattr. While slightly less convenient ioctl does not have the same problems and will be the main API going forward.
The keys are the same as the command line option arguments as well as the config file.
##### requests / commands
All commands take a 4096 byte char buffer.
* read keys: get a nul '\0' delimited list of option keys
* _IOWR(0xDF,0,char[4096]) = 0xD000DF00
* on success ioctl return value is the total length
* read value: get an option value
* _IOWR(0xDF,1,char[4096]) = 0xD000DF01
* the key is passed in via the char buffer as a nul '\0' terminated string
* on success ioctl return value is the total length
* write value: set an option value
* _IOW(0xDF,2,char[4096]) = 0x5000DF02
* the key and value is passed in via the char buffer as a nul '\0' terminated string in the format of `key=value`
* on success ioctl return value is 0
* file info: get mergerfs metadata info for a file
* _IOWR(0xDF,3,char[4096]) = 0xD000DF03
* the key is passed in via the char buffer as a nul '\0' terminated string
* on success the ioctl return value is the total length
* keys:
* basepath: the base mount point for the file according to the getattr policy
* relpath: the relative path of the file from the mount point
* fullpath: the full path of the underlying file according to the getattr policy
* allpaths: a NUL '\0' delimited list of full paths to all files found
#### .mergerfs pseudo file (deprecated) ####
NOTE: this interface will be removed in mergerfs 3.0
There is a pseudo file available at the mount point which allows for the runtime modification of certain **mergerfs** options. The file will not show up in **readdir** but can be **stat**'ed and manipulated via [{list,get,set}xattrs](http://linux.die.net/man/2/listxattr) calls.
Any changes made at runtime are **not** persisted. If you wish for values to persist they must be included as options wherever you configure the mounting of mergerfs (/etc/fstab).
Use `xattr -l /mountpoint/.mergerfs` to see all supported keys. Some are informational and therefore read-only. `setxattr` will return EINVAL (invalid argument) on read-only keys.
While they won't show up when using [listxattr](http://linux.die.net/man/2/listxattr) **mergerfs** offers a number of special xattrs to query information about the files served. To access the values you will need to issue a [getxattr](http://linux.die.net/man/2/getxattr) for one of the following:
mergerfs can be upgraded live by mounting on top of the previous version. Simply install the new version of mergerfs and follow the instructions below.
Add `nonempty` to your mergerfs option list and call mergerfs again or if using `/etc/fstab` call for it to mount again. Existing open files and such will continue to work fine though they won't see runtime changes since any such change would be the new mount. If you plan on changing settings with the new mount you should / could apply those before mounting the new version.
```
$ sudo mount /mnt/mergerfs
$ mount | grep mergerfs
media on /mnt/mergerfs type fuse.mergerfs (rw,relatime,user_id=0,group_id=0,default_permissions,allow_other)
media on /mnt/mergerfs type fuse.mergerfs (rw,relatime,user_id=0,group_id=0,default_permissions,allow_other)
* cache.files=auto-full: Enables page caching. Underlying files cached, mergerfs files cached across opens if mtime and size are unchanged since previous open.
FUSE, which mergerfs uses, offers a number of page caching modes. mergerfs tries to simplify their use via the `cache.files` option. It can and should replace usage of `direct_io`, `kernel_cache`, and `auto_cache`.
Due to mergerfs using FUSE and therefore being a userland process proxying existing filesystems the kernel will double cache the content being read and written through mergerfs. Once from the underlying filesystem and once from mergerfs (it sees them as two separate entities). Using `cache.files=off` will keep the double caching from happening by disabling caching of mergerfs but this has the side effect that *all* read and write calls will be passed to mergerfs which may be slower than enabling caching, you lose shared `mmap` support which can affect apps such as rtorrent, and no read-ahead will take place. The kernel will still cache the underlying filesystem data but that only helps so much given mergerfs will still process all requests.
If you do enable file page caching, `cache.files=partial|full|auto-full`, you should also enable `dropcacheonclose` which will cause mergerfs to instruct the kernel to flush the underlying file's page cache when the file is closed. This behavior is the same as the rsync fadvise / drop cache patch and Feh's nocache project.
If most files are read once through and closed (like media) it is best to enable `dropcacheonclose` regardless of caching mode in order to minimize buffer bloat.
It is difficult to balance memory usage, cache bloat & duplication, and performance. Ideally mergerfs would be able to disable caching for the files it reads/writes but allow page caching for itself. That would limit the FUSE overhead. However, there isn't a good way to achieve this. It would need to open all files with O_DIRECT which places limitations on the what underlying filesystems would be supported and complicates the code.
Given the relatively high cost of FUSE due to the kernel <-> userspace round trips there are kernel side caches for file entries and attributes. The entry cache limits the `lookup` calls to mergerfs which ask if a file exists. The attribute cache limits the need to make `getattr` calls to mergerfs which provide file attributes (mode, size, type, etc.). As with the page cache these should not be used if the underlying filesystems are being manipulated at the same time as it could lead to odd behavior or data corruption. The options for setting these are `cache.entry` and `cache.negative_entry` for the entry cache and `cache.attr` for the attributes cache. `cache.negative_entry` refers to the timeout for negative responses to lookups (non-existent files).
When `cache.files` is enabled the default is for it to perform writethrough caching. This behavior won't help improve performance as each write still goes one for one through the filesystem. By enabling the FUSE writeback cache small writes may be aggregated by the kernel and then sent to mergerfs as one larger request. This can greatly improve the throughput for apps which write to files inefficiently. The amount the kernel can aggregate is limited by the size of a FUSE message. Read the `fuse_msg_size` section for more details.
There is a small side effect as a result of enabling wrtieback caching. Underlying files won't ever be opened with O_APPEND or O_WRONLY. The former because the kernel then manages append mode and the latter because the kernel may request file data from mergerfs to populate the write cache. The O_APPEND change means that if a file is changed outside of mergerfs it could lead to corruption as the kernel won't know the end of the file has changed. That said any time you use caching you should keep from using the same file outside of mergerfs at the same time.
Note that if an application is properly sizing writes then writeback caching will have little or no effect. It will only help with writes of sizes below the FUSE message size (128K on older kernels, 1M on newer).
Policies are run every time a function (with a policy as mentioned above) is called. These policies can be expensive depending on mergerfs' setup and client usage patterns. Generally we wouldn't want to cache policy results because it may result in stale responses if the underlying drives are used directly.
The `open` policy cache will cache the result of an `open` policy for a particular input for `cache.open` seconds or until the file is unlinked. Each file close (release) will randomly chose to clean up the cache of expired entries.
This cache is really only useful in cases where you have a large number of branches and `open` is called on the same files repeatedly (like **Transmission** which opens and closes a file on every read/write presumably to keep file handle usage low).
Of the syscalls used by mergerfs in policies the `statfs` / `statvfs` call is perhaps the most expensive. It's used to find out the available space of a drive and whether it is mounted read-only. Depending on the setup and usage pattern these queries can be relatively costly. When `cache.statfs` is enabled all calls to `statfs` by a policy will be cached for the number of seconds its set to.
Example: If the create policy is `mfs` and the timeout is 60 then for that 60 seconds the same drive will be returned as the target for creates because the available space won't be updated for that time.
As of version 4.20 Linux supports symlink caching. Significant performance increases can be had in workloads which use a lot of symlinks. Setting `cache.symlinks=true` will result in requesting symlink caching from the kernel only if supported. As a result its safe to enable it on systems prior to 4.20. That said it is disabled by default for now. You can see if caching is enabled by querying the xattr `user.mergerfs.cache.symlinks` but given it must be requested at startup you can not change it at runtime.
As of version 4.20 Linux supports readdir caching. This can have a significant impact on directory traversal. Especially when combined with entry (`cache.entry`) and attribute (`cache.attr`) caching. Setting `cache.readdir=true` will result in requesting readdir caching from the kernel on each `opendir`. If the kernel doesn't support readdir caching setting the option to `true` has no effect. This option is configurable at runtime via xattr `user.mergerfs.cache.readdir`.
Some storage technologies support what some call "tiered" caching. The placing of usually smaller, faster storage as a transparent cache to larger, slower storage. NVMe, SSD, Optane in front of traditional HDDs for instance.
MergerFS does not natively support any sort of tiered caching. Most users have no use for such a feature and its inclusion would complicate the code. However, there are a few situations where a cache drive could help with a typical mergerfs setup.
1. Fast network, slow drives, many readers: You've a 10+Gbps network with many readers and your regular drives can't keep up.
2. Fast network, slow drives, small'ish bursty writes: You have a 10+Gbps network and wish to transfer amounts of data less than your cache drive but wish to do so quickly.
With #1 its arguable if you should be using mergerfs at all. RAID would probably be the better solution. If you're going to use mergerfs there are other tactics that may help: spreading the data across drives (see the mergerfs.dup tool) and setting `func.open=rand`, using `symlinkify`, or using dm-cache or a similar technology to add tiered cache to the underlying device.
With #2 one could use dm-cache as well but there is another solution which requires only mergerfs and a cronjob.
3. The best `create` policies to use for the 'cache' pool would probably be `ff`, `epff`, `lfs`, or `eplfs`. The latter two under the assumption that the cache drive(s) are far smaller than the backing drives. If using path preserving policies remember that you'll need to manually create the core directories of those paths you wish to be cached. Be sure the permissions are in sync. Use `mergerfs.fsck` to check / correct them. You could also tag the slow drives as `=NC` though that'd mean if the cache drives fill you'd get "out of space" errors.
4. Enable `moveonenospc` and set `minfreespace` appropriately. To make sure there is enough room on the "slow" pool you might want to set `minfreespace` to at least as large as the size of the largest cache drive if not larger. This way in the worst case the whole of the cache drive(s) can be moved to the other drives.
Move files from cache to backing pool based only on the last time the file was accessed. Replace `-atime` with `-amin` if you want minutes rather than days. May want to use the `fadvise` / `--drop-cache` version of rsync or run rsync with the tool "nocache".
mergerfs is at its core just a proxy and therefore its theoretical max performance is that of the underlying devices. However, given it is a FUSE filesystem working from userspace there is an increase in overhead relative to kernel based solutions. That said the performance can match the theoretical max but it depends greatly on the system's configuration. Especially when adding network filesystems into the mix there are many variables which can impact performance. Drive speeds and latency, network speeds and latency, general concurrency, read/write sizes, etc. Unfortunately, given the number of variables it has been difficult to find a single set of settings which provide optimal performance. If you're having performance issues please look over the suggestions below (including the benchmarking section.)
If you come across a setting that significantly impacts performance please contact trapexit so he may investigate further.
# BENCHMARKING
Filesystems are complicated. They do many things and many of those are interconnected. Additionally, the OS, drivers, hardware, etc. all can impact performance. Therefore, when benchmarking, it is **necessary** that the test focus as narrowly as possible.
For most throughput is the key benchmark. To test throughput `dd` is useful but **must** be used with the correct settings in order to ensure the filesystem or device is actually being tested. The OS can and will cache data. Without forcing synchronous reads and writes and/or disabling caching the values returned will not be representative of the device's true performance.
When benchmarking through mergerfs ensure you only use 1 branch to remove any possibility of the policies complicating the situation. Benchmark the underlying filesystem first and then mount mergerfs over it and test again. If you're experience speeds below your expectation you will need to narrow down precisely which component is leading to the slowdown. Preferably test the following in the order listed (but not combined).
1. Enable `nullrw` mode with `nullrw=true`. This will effectively make reads and writes no-ops. Removing the underlying device / filesystem from the equation. This will give us the top theoretical speeds.
2. Mount mergerfs over `tmpfs`. `tmpfs` is a RAM disk. Extremely high speed and very low latency. This is a more realistic best case scenario. Example: `mount -t tmpfs -o size=2G tmpfs /tmp/tmpfs`
3. Mount mergerfs over a local drive. NVMe, SSD, HDD, etc. If you have more than one I'd suggest testing each of them as drives and/or controllers (their drivers) could impact performance.
4. Finally, if you intend to use mergerfs with a network filesystem, either as the source of data or to combine with another through mergerfs, test each of those alone as above.
Once you find the component which has the performance issue you can do further testing with different options to see if they impact performance. For reads and writes the most relevant would be: `cache.files`, `async_read`, `splice_move`, `splice_read`, `splice_write`. Less likely but relevant when using NFS or with certain filesystems would be `security_capability`, `xattr`, and `posix_acl`. If you find a specific system, drive, filesystem, controller, etc. that performs poorly contact trapexit so he may investigate further.
Sometimes the problem is really the application accessing or writing data through mergerfs. Some software use small buffer sizes which can lead to more requests and therefore greater overhead. You can test this out yourself by replace `bs=1M` in the examples below with `ibs` or `obs` and using a size of `512` instead of `1M`. In one example test using `nullrw` the write speed dropped from 4.9GB/s to 69.7MB/s when moving from `1M` to `512`. Similar results were had when testing reads. Small writes overhead may be improved by leveraging a write cache but in casual tests little gain was found. More tests will need to be done before this feature would become available. If you have an app that appears slow with mergerfs it could be due to this. Contact trapexit so he may investigate further.
* **use_ino** will only work when used with mergerfs 2.18.0 and above.
* Run mergerfs as `root` (with **allow_other**) unless you're merging paths which are owned by the same user otherwise strange permission issues may arise.
* https://github.com/trapexit/backup-and-recovery-howtos : A set of guides / howtos on creating a data storage system, backing it up, maintaining it, and recovering from failure.
* If you don't see some directories and files you expect in a merged point or policies seem to skip drives be sure the user has permission to all the underlying directories. Use `mergerfs.fsck` to audit the drive for out of sync permissions.
* Do **not** use `cache.files=off` (or `direct_io`) if you expect applications (such as rtorrent) to [mmap](http://linux.die.net/man/2/mmap) files. Shared mmap is not currently supported in FUSE w/ `direct_io` enabled. Enabling `dropcacheonclose` is recommended when `cache.files=partial|full|auto-full` or `direct_io=false`.
* Since POSIX functions give only a singular error or success its difficult to determine the proper behavior when applying the function to multiple targets. **mergerfs** will return an error only if all attempts of an action fail. Any success will lead to a success returned. This means however that some odd situations may arise.
* [Kodi](http://kodi.tv), [Plex](http://plex.tv), [Subsonic](http://subsonic.org), etc. can use directory [mtime](http://linux.die.net/man/2/stat) to more efficiently determine whether to scan for new content rather than simply performing a full scan. If using the default **getattr** policy of **ff** it's possible those programs will miss an update on account of it returning the first directory found's **stat** info and its a later directory on another mount which had the **mtime** recently updated. To fix this you will want to set **func.getattr=newest**. Remember though that this is just **stat**. If the file is later **open**'ed or **unlink**'ed and the policy is different for those then a completely different file or directory could be acted on.
* Some policies mixed with some functions may result in strange behaviors. Not that some of these behaviors and race conditions couldn't happen outside **mergerfs** but that they are far more likely to occur on account of the attempt to merge together multiple sources of data which could be out of sync due to the different policies.
* For consistency its generally best to set **category** wide policies rather than individual **func**'s. This will help limit the confusion of tools such as [rsync](http://linux.die.net/man/1/rsync). However, the flexibility is there if needed.
Remember that the default policy for `getattr` is `ff`. The information for the first directory found will be returned. If it wasn't the directory which had been updated then it will appear outdated.
The reason this is the default is because any other policy would be more expensive and for many applications it is unnecessary. To always return the directory with the most recent mtime or a faked value based on all found would require a scan of all drives.
ls: cannot access '/mnt/pool/foo': No such file or directory
```
`mv`, when working across devices, is copying the source to target and then removing the source. Since the source **is** the target in this case, depending on the unlink policy, it will remove the just copied file and other files across the branches.
If you want to move files to one drive just copy them there and use mergerfs.dedup to clean up the old paths or manually remove them from the branches directly.
Be sure to set `cache.files=partial|full|auto-full` or turn off `direct_io`. rtorrent and some other applications use [mmap](http://linux.die.net/man/2/mmap) to read and write to files and offer no fallback to traditional methods. FUSE does not currently support mmap while using `direct_io`. There may be a performance penalty on writes with `direct_io` off as well as the problem of double caching but it's the only way to get such applications to work. If the performance loss is too high for other apps you can mount mergerfs twice. Once with `direct_io` enabled and one without it. Be sure to set `dropcacheonclose=true` if not using `direct_io`.
There appears to be a bug in the OpenVZ kernel with regard to how it handles ioctl calls. It is making invalid requests which leads to a crash. As of 2019-12-10 there is a bug report filed with OpenVZ but it is not yet fixed.
It does. If you're trying to put Plex's config / metadata on mergerfs you have to leave `direct_io` off because Plex is using sqlite3 which apparently needs mmap. mmap doesn't work with `direct_io`. To fix this place the data elsewhere or disable `direct_io` (with `dropcacheonclose=true`). Sqlite3 does not need mmap but the developer needs to fall back to standard IO if mmap fails.
There [is/was a bug](https://lkml.org/lkml/2016/3/16/260) in caching which affects overall performance of mmap through FUSE in Linux 4.x kernels. It is fixed in [4.4.10 and 4.5.4](https://lkml.org/lkml/2016/5/11/59).
The problem is that many applications do not properly handle `EXDEV` errors which `rename` and `link` may return even though they are perfectly valid situations which do not indicate actual drive or OS errors. The error will only be returned by mergerfs if using a path preserving policy as described in the policy section above. If you do not care about path preservation simply change the mergerfs policy to the non-path preserving version. For example: `-o category.create=mfs`
Ideally the offending software would be fixed and it is recommended that if you run into this problem you contact the software's author and request proper handling of `EXDEV` errors.
This isn't an issue with Samba but some SMB clients. GVFS-fuse v1.20.3 and prior (found in Ubuntu 14.04 among others) failed to handle certain error codes correctly. Particularly **STATUS_NOT_SAME_DEVICE** which comes from the **EXDEV** which is returned by **rename** when the call is crossing mount points. When a program gets an **EXDEV** it needs to explicitly take an alternate action to accomplish its goal. In the case of **mv** or similar it tries **rename** and on **EXDEV** falls back to a manual copying of data between the two locations and unlinking the source. In these older versions of GVFS-fuse if it received **EXDEV** it would translate that into **EIO**. This would cause **mv** or most any application attempting to move files around on that SMB share to fail with a IO error.
[GVFS-fuse v1.22.0](https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=734568) and above fixed this issue but a large number of systems use the older release. On Ubuntu the version can be checked by issuing `apt-cache showpkg gvfs-fuse`. Most distros released in 2015 seem to have the updated release and will work fine but older systems may not. Upgrading gvfs-fuse or the distro in general will address the problem.
In Apple's MacOSX 10.9 they replaced Samba (client and server) with their own product. It appears their new client does not handle **EXDEV** either and responds similar to older release of gvfs on Linux.
This is the same issue as with Samba. `rename` returns `EXDEV` (in our case that will really only happen with path preserving policies like `epmfs`) and the software doesn't handle the situation well. This is unfortunately a common failure of software which moves files around. The standard indicates that an implementation `MAY` choose to support non-user home directory trashing of files (which is a `MUST`). The implementation `MAY` also support "top directory trashes" which many probably do.
To create a `$topdir/.Trash` directory as defined in the standard use the [mergerfs-tools](https://github.com/trapexit/mergerfs-tools) tool `mergerfs.mktrash`.
Due to the overhead of [getgroups/setgroups](http://linux.die.net/man/2/setgroups) mergerfs utilizes a cache. This cache is opportunistic and per thread. Each thread will query the supplemental groups for a user when that particular thread needs to change credentials and will keep that data for the lifetime of the thread. This means that if a user is added to a group it may not be picked up without the restart of mergerfs. However, since the high level FUSE API's (at least the standard version) thread pool dynamically grows and shrinks it's possible that over time a thread will be killed and later a new thread with no cache will start and query the new data.
The gid cache uses fixed storage to simplify the design and be compatible with older systems which may not have C++11 compilers. There is enough storage for 256 users' supplemental groups. Each user is allowed up to 32 supplemental groups. Linux >= 2.6.3 allows up to 65535 groups per user but most other *nixs allow far less. NFS allowing only 16. The system does handle overflow gracefully. If the user has more than 32 supplemental groups only the first 32 will be used. If more than 256 users are using the system when an uncached user is found it will evict an existing user's cache at random. So long as there aren't more than 256 active users this should be fine. If either value is too low for your needs you will have to modify `gidcache.hpp` to increase the values. Note that doing so will increase the memory needed by each thread.
While not a bug some users have found when using containers that supplemental groups defined inside the container don't work properly with regard to permissions. This is expected as mergerfs lives outside the container and therefore is querying the host's group database. There might be a hack to work around this (make mergerfs read the /etc/group file in the container) but it is not yet implemented and would be limited to Linux and the /etc/group DB. Preferably users would mount in the host group file into the containers or use a standard shared user & groups technology like NIS or LDAP.
If suddenly the mergerfs mount point disappears and `Transport endpoint is not connected` is returned when attempting to perform actions within the mount directory **and** the version of libfuse (use `mergerfs -v` to find the version) is older than `2.9.4` its likely due to a bug in libfuse. Affected versions of libfuse can be found in Debian Wheezy, Ubuntu Precise and others.
In order to fix this please install newer versions of libfuse. If using a Debian based distro (Debian,Ubuntu,Mint) you can likely just install newer versions of [libfuse](https://packages.debian.org/unstable/libfuse2) and [fuse](https://packages.debian.org/unstable/fuse) from the repo of a newer release.
There seems to be an issue with Linux version `4.9.0` and above in which an invalid message appears to be transmitted to libfuse (used by mergerfs) causing it to exit. No messages will be printed in any logs as it's not a proper crash. Debugging of the issue is still ongoing and can be followed via the [fuse-devel thread](https://sourceforge.net/p/fuse/mailman/message/35662577).
There is a bug in the kernel. A work around appears to be turning off `splice`. Don't add the `splice_*` arguments or add `no_splice_write,no_splice_move,no_splice_read`. This, however, is not guaranteed to work.
Users have reported running mergerfs on everything from a Raspberry Pi to dual socket Xeon systems with >20 cores. I'm aware of at least a few companies which use mergerfs in production. [Open Media Vault](https://www.openmediavault.org) includes mergerfs as its sole solution for pooling drives.
MergerFS is **not** a traditional filesystem. MergerFS is **not** RAID. It does **not** manipulate the data that passes through it. It does **not** shard data across drives. It merely shards some **behavior** and aggregates others.
Unless you're doing something more niche the average user is probably best off using `mfs` for `category.create`. It will spread files out across your branches based on available space. You may want to use `lus` if you prefer a slightly different distribution of data if you have a mix of smaller and larger drives. Generally though `mfs`, `lus`, or even `rand` are good for the general use case. If you are starting with an imbalanced pool you can use the tool **mergerfs.balance** to redistribute files across the pool.
If you really wish to try to colocate files based on directory you can set `func.create` to `epmfs` or similar and `func.mkdir` to `rand` or `eprand` depending on if you just want to colocate generally or on specific branches. Either way the *need* to colocate is rare. For instance: if you wish to remove the drive regularly and want the data to predictably be on that drive or if you don't use backup at all and don't wish to replace that data piecemeal. In which case using path preservation can help but will require some manual attention. Colocating after the fact can be accomplished using the **mergerfs.consolidate** tool.
Ultimately there is no correct answer. It is a preference or based on some particular need. mergerfs is very easy to test and experiment with. I suggest creating a test setup and experimenting to get a sense of what you want.
The reason `mfs` is not the default `category.create` policy is historical. When/if a 3.X gets released it will be changed to minimize confusion people often have with path preserving policies.
Depends on what features you want. Generally speaking there are no "wrong" settings. All settings are performance or feature related. The best bet is to read over the available options and choose what fits your situation. If something isn't clear from the documentation please reach out and the documentation will be improved.
That said, for the average person, the following should be fine:
The default create policy is `epmfs`. That is a path preserving algorithm. With such a policy for `mkdir` and `create` with a set of empty drives it will select only 1 drive when the first directory is created. Anything, files or directories, created in that first directory will be placed on the same branch because it is preserving paths.
This catches a lot of new users off guard but changing the default would break the setup for many existing users. If you do not care about path preservation and wish your files to be spread across all your drives change to `mfs` or similar policy as described above. If you do want path preservation you'll need to perform the manual act of creating paths on the drives you want the data to land on before transferring your data. Setting `func.mkdir=epall` can simplify managing path preservation for `create`. Or use `func.mkdir=rand` if you're interested in just grouping together directory content by drive.
Not in the sense of a filesystem like BTRFS or ZFS nor in the overlayfs or aufs sense. It does offer a [cow-shell](http://manpages.ubuntu.com/manpages/bionic/man1/cow-shell.1.html) like hard link breaking (copy to temp file then rename over original) which can be useful when wanting to save space by hardlinking duplicate files but wish to treat each name as if it were a unique and separate file.
It's almost always a permissions issue. Unlike mhddfs and unionfs-fuse, which runs as root and attempts to access content as such, mergerfs always changes its credentials to that of the caller. This means that if the user does not have access to a file or directory than neither will mergerfs. However, because mergerfs is creating a union of paths it may be able to read some files and directories on one drive but not another resulting in an incomplete set.
Whenever you run into a split permission issue (seeing some but not all files) try using [mergerfs.fsck](https://github.com/trapexit/mergerfs-tools) tool to check for and fix the mismatch. If you aren't seeing anything at all be sure that the basic permissions are correct. The user and group values are correct and that directories have their executable bit set. A common mistake by users new to Linux is to `chmod -R 644` when they should have `chmod -R u=rwX,go=rX`.
If using a network filesystem such as NFS, SMB, CIFS (Samba) be sure to pay close attention to anything regarding permissioning and users. Root squashing and user translation for instance has bitten a few mergerfs users. Some of these also affect the use of mergerfs from container platforms such as Docker.
#### Is my OS's libfuse needed for mergerfs to work?
No. Normally `mount.fuse` is needed to get mergerfs (or any FUSE filesystem to mount using the `mount` command but in vendoring the libfuse library the `mount.fuse` app has been renamed to `mount.mergerfs` meaning the filesystem type in `fstab` can simply be `mergerfs`.
1. A significant number of users use mergerfs on distros with old versions of libfuse which have serious bugs. Requiring updated versions of libfuse on those distros isn't practical (no package offered, user inexperience, etc.). The only practical way to provide a stable runtime on those systems was to "vendor" / embed the library into the project.
2. mergerfs was written to use the high level API. There are a number of limitations in the HLAPI that make certain features difficult or impossible to implement. While some of these features could be patched into newer versions of libfuse without breaking the public API some of them would require hacky code to provide backwards compatibility. While it may still be worth working with upstream to address these issues in future versions, since the library needs to be vendored for stability and compatibility reasons it is preferable / easier to modify the API. Longer term the plan is to rewrite mergerfs to use the low level API.
#### Why did support for system libfuse get removed?
See above first.
If/when mergerfs is rewritten to use the low-level API then it'll be plausible to support system libfuse but till then its simply too much work to manage the differences across the versions.
mhddfs is no longer maintained and has some known stability and security issues (see below). MergerFS provides a superset of mhddfs' features and should offer the same or maybe better performance.
While aufs can offer better peak performance mergerfs provides more configurability and is generally easier to use. mergerfs however does not offer the overlay / copy-on-write (CoW) features which aufs and overlayfs have.
UnionFS is more like aufs than mergerfs in that it offers overlay / CoW features. If you're just looking to create a union of drives and want flexibility in file/directory placement then mergerfs offers that whereas unionfs is more for overlaying RW filesystems over RO ones.
With simple JBOD / drive concatenation / stripping / RAID0 a single drive failure will result in full pool failure. mergerfs performs a similar function without the possibility of catastrophic failure and the difficulties in recovery. Drives may fail, however, all other data will continue to be accessible.
When combined with something like [SnapRaid](http://www.snapraid.it) and/or an offsite backup solution you can have the flexibility of JBOD without the single point of failure.
MergerFS is not intended to be a replacement for ZFS. MergerFS is intended to provide flexible pooling of arbitrary drives (local or remote), of arbitrary sizes, and arbitrary filesystems. For `write once, read many` usecases such as bulk media storage. Where data integrity and backup is managed in other ways. In that situation ZFS can introduce a number of costs and limitations as described [here](http://louwrentius.com/the-hidden-cost-of-using-zfs-for-your-home-nas.html), [here](https://markmcb.com/2020/01/07/five-years-of-btrfs/), and [here](https://utcc.utoronto.ca/~cks/space/blog/solaris/ZFSWhyNoRealReshaping).
UnRAID is a full OS and its storage layer, as I understand, is proprietary and closed source. Users who have experience with both have said they prefer the flexibility offered by mergerfs and for some the fact it is free and open source is important.
* databases: Even if the database stored data in separate files (mergerfs wouldn't offer much otherwise) the higher latency of the indirection will kill performance. If it is a lightly used SQLITE database then it may be fine but you'll need to test.
* VM images: For the same reasons as databases. VM images are accessed very aggressively and mergerfs will introduce too much latency (if it works at all).
* As replacement for RAID: mergerfs is just for pooling branches. If you need that kind of device performance aggregation or high availability you should stick with RAID.
Yes, however it's not recommended to use the same file from within the pool and from without at the same time (particularly writing). Especially if using caching of any kind (cache.files, cache.entry, cache.attr, cache.negative_entry, cache.symlinks, cache.readdir, etc.) as there could be a conflict between cached data and not.
First make sure you've read the sections above about policies, path preservation, branch filtering, and the options **minfreespace**, **moveonenospc**, **statfs**, and **statfs_ignore**.
mergerfs is simply presenting a union of the content within multiple branches. The reported free space is an aggregate of space available within the pool (behavior modified by **statfs** and **statfs_ignore**). It does not represent a contiguous space. In the same way that read-only filesystems, those with quotas, or reserved space report the full theoretical space available.
Due to path preservation, branch tagging, read-only status, and **minfreespace** settings it is perfectly valid that `ENOSPC` / "out of space" / "no space left on device" be returned. It is doing what was asked of it: filtering possible branches due to those settings. Only one error can be returned and if one of the reasons for filtering a branch was **minfreespace** then it will be returned as such. **moveonenospc** is only relevant to writing a file which is too large for the drive its currently on.
If you don't care about path preservation then simply change the `create` policy to one which isn't. `mfs` is probably what most are looking for. The reason it's not default is because it was originally set to `epmfs` and changing it now would change people's setup. Such a setting change will likely occur in mergerfs 3.
#### Why does the total available space in mergerfs not equal outside?
Are you using ext4? With reserve for root? mergerfs uses available space for statfs calculations. If you've reserved space for root then it won't show up.
Yes, however if you do anything which may changes files out of band (including for example using the `newest` policy) it will result in "stale file handle" errors.
#### I notice massive slowdowns of writes when enabling cache.files.
When file caching is enabled in any form (`cache.files!=off` or `direct_io=false`) it will issue `getxattr` requests for `security.capability` prior to *every single write*. This will usually result in a performance degregation, especially when using a network filesystem (such as NFS or CIFS/SMB/Samba.) Unfortunately at this moment the kernel is not caching the response.
To work around this situation mergerfs offers a few solutions.
1. Set `security_capability=false`. It will short circuit any call and return `ENOATTR`. This still means though that mergerfs will receive the request before every write but at least it doesn't get passed through to the underlying filesystem.
2. Set `xattr=noattr`. Same as above but applies to *all* calls to getxattr. Not just `security.capability`. This will not be cached by the kernel either but mergerfs' runtime config system will still function.
3. Set `xattr=nosys`. Results in mergerfs returning `ENOSYS` which *will* be cached by the kernel. No future xattr calls will be forwarded to mergerfs. The downside is that also means the xattr based config and query functionality won't work either.
4. Disable file caching. If you aren't using applications which use `mmap` it's probably simpler to just disable it all together. The kernel won't send the requests when caching is disabled.
[mhddfs](https://github.com/trapexit/mhddfs) manages running as **root** by calling [getuid()](https://github.com/trapexit/mhddfs/blob/cae96e6251dd91e2bdc24800b4a18a74044f6672/src/main.c#L319) and if it returns **0** then it will [chown](http://linux.die.net/man/1/chown) the file. Not only is that a race condition but it doesn't handle other situations. Rather than attempting to simulate POSIX ACL behavior the proper way to manage this is to use [seteuid](http://linux.die.net/man/2/seteuid) and [setegid](http://linux.die.net/man/2/setegid), in effect becoming the user making the original call, and perform the action as them. This is what mergerfs does and why mergerfs should always run as root.
In Linux setreuid syscalls apply only to the thread. GLIBC hides this away by using realtime signals to inform all threads to change credentials. Taking after **Samba**, mergerfs uses **syscall(SYS_setreuid,...)** to set the callers credentials for that thread only. Jumping back to **root** as necessary should escalated privileges be needed (for instance: to clone paths between drives).
For non-Linux systems mergerfs uses a read-write lock and changes credentials only when necessary. If multiple threads are to be user X then only the first one will need to change the processes credentials. So long as the other threads need to be user X they will take a readlock allowing multiple threads to share the credentials. Once a request comes in to run as user Y that thread will attempt a write lock and change to Y's credentials when it can. If the ability to give writers priority is supported then that flag will be used so threads trying to change credentials don't starve. This isn't the best solution but should work reasonably well assuming there are few users.
Filesystems are complex and difficult to debug. mergerfs, while being just a proxy of sorts, is also very difficult to debug given the large number of possible settings it can have itself and the massive number of environments it can run in. When reporting on a suspected issue **please, please** include as much of the below information as possible otherwise it will be difficult or impossible to diagnose. Also please make sure to read all of the above documentation as it includes nearly every known system or user issue previously encountered.
**Please make sure you are using the [latest release](https://github.com/trapexit/mergerfs/releases) or have tried it in comparison. Old versions, which are often included in distros like Debian and Ubuntu, are not ever going to be updated and your bug may have been addressed already.**
This software is free to use and released under a very liberal license. That said if you like this software and would like to support its development donations are welcome.
